To eat in or not

inspiration, Kitchen July 19, 2010

In our discussions here about the future layout and floorplan of the kitchen reno we seem to have hit a point of contention! We agree on appliances, colors, materials, pretty much everything except for placement of our future eatting area. I LOVE our giant, sunny nook, but Sean would prefer to see it become a sunny reading room. He proposes to move the dining table and chairs to the middle of the kitchen and go with a smaller island, while I would like to see them stay put and have a larger work space.

With the hardwood floors installed, beadboard ceiling up, a new light fixture and some roman blinds I think this will be the perfect spot to share a bowl of cereal everyday.

What are your thoughts?

But in the meantime I have been debating on whether to go with a more dramatic crystal chandelier or a somewhat sleeker lantern-like fixture. And here are some of my favorite “nooks” that have me all inspired, yet confused as to what direction we should go in.


Comments 41

  1. Kerry says on July 19, 2010

    I'm with you! That dining nook is in the perfect spot with all of those windows. I wish we had a sunny spot like that to enjoy our breakfast in the morning!


  2. lauren @ gathering moss says on July 19, 2010

    go with the lantern! you could also build in a window seat bench and guess what, instant reading nook. everybody wins! y'all are totally handy enough to pull it off with some diy action.


  3. Rene says on July 19, 2010

    That looks like the perfect place for a table and I love the lantern idea. Can't wait to see what you decide.



  4. Jen says on July 19, 2010

    i think having chairs for part of your table and then adding a padded bench for the other side would be a great compromise. your hubby can kick his feet up & read in his nook while you eat snacks & cozy up with him! maybe you could even put some bins under your windows full of your favorite reads….

    i have no suggestions for lighting… love them all. i think i was especially drawn to that neat lantern picture but i think it may depend on what the rest of the room looks like…


  5. Caroline @ The Feminist Housewife says on July 19, 2010

    Such a gorgeous nook…I don't think you can go wrong either way. I guess it just depends whether you'd like to have another spot to curl up with a book or not! ; ) Also, I'm almost always a fan of more kitchen space…


  6. christine says on July 19, 2010

    That is just the perfect little breakfast nook – it so sunny and sweet! I would keep the table – heck, you can read at a table can't you ;)


  7. Holly and Sean says on July 19, 2010

    Great suggestion with the built in seating everyone! The only issue is that the windows go lower than seat-level, and we would need a HUGE table to cover the whole room.
    I already told Sean that we have a living room, family room, chairs in Wren's room, and a couch in our room. I think we have plenty of reading spots LOL.


  8. Ashley says on July 19, 2010

    surely there are plenty of other nice places in your house to sit and read, I say leave the table :o)


  9. Miss Money says on July 19, 2010

    Why not have a beautiful cushy slipcovered love seat on one side of a square/rectangular table…You both can win! He can sit on the loveseat & read, you can dine at your table….I like the 1st, 2nd, and last light fixtures. Have a great week!


  10. Paint Me White says on July 19, 2010

    Holly the dining nook in perfect where you have it. Sean's idean in theory sounds wonderful but we have a room that we dedicate to reading etc and it hardly ever gets used. That current dining space is such a wonderful area to sit and eat, I would leave it as is. Sandy x


  11. 40daysof says on July 19, 2010

    If the position of the table now limits it's size, then go with Sean's idea. Otherwise, all of the comments have great ideas as you've already seen. I can just imagine a time when Wren and possibly other kids have friends over and you wish the kitchen table could be bigger on a permanent basis. Also, you thought a couch in the master might be weird, but you love it. You'll probably love a couch in the kitchen, too.


  12. Apple Box Boutique says on July 19, 2010

    Go for the best of both worlds! Bring the table out a little and do a built-in window seat, resplendent and comfy for reading. It can double as extra seating around the sunny breakfast nook table if you move the chairs off to the side, leaves enough room for a medium/large island, and offers a nice little reading nook for Sean.


  13. maria marks says on July 19, 2010

    Keep the nook for dining/breakfast. There's never enough counter space and people always gather in the kitchen during parties so it needs to have open space…….


  14. Jessica says on July 19, 2010

    Hi Holly,

    I really like to location of your kitchen table…it was a perfect spot for crafting anyways! My suggestion would be to either have a build in cozy area like the last two pics or a cozy chair on one side. Then you both kind of win!

    Jess Xox


  15. Audra says on July 19, 2010

    I would leave the table as well. Maybe you could incorporate benches under the windows with open shelves below for books….. Trying to fit both of your wants! Can't wait to see it.


  16. Tiffany says on July 20, 2010

    I agree with the girls who suggested a bench on one side and chairs on the other…then he can “recline” to read on the bench! I think lanterns would be more fun and less expected!


  17. Lovely Little Nest says on July 20, 2010

    The question is: Which space would cause you to spend more time in the nook?

    Will you really be spending a lot of time eating cereal there? If not, I say go with the reading nook.


  18. Mandie says on July 20, 2010

    I love your little table in the nook! It looks perfect to me, but if you wanted to kinda split the middle with your hubby, you could make the reading area in the nook, use your dining room for all your eating, and keep all your workspace in the kitchen itself. I think it will be lovely any way you go with it!


  19. The Chatelaine says on July 20, 2010

    I would say dining space over reading nook. It'll be a great spot for homework, someday, too! The light fixture could go either way. I like the idea of a more formal chandelier — all that sunlight glinting off the crystals — but I'm also a sucker for a good lantern.

    Thanks for sharing!

    Abigail @ Raising Camelot


  20. Douglas says on July 20, 2010

    So how about using an arm chair or two at the table…unique seating and comfortable for leisure time at the table for games, cards, discussions or reading! And I would definitely go with a sparkly chandelier. I think dining areas need less clutter, so a chandelier would add sparkle and glamor without the STUFF. Can't wait to see/hear what you decide!


  21. Sixty-Fifth Avenue says on July 20, 2010

    I agree with you for sure! That is a beautiful eating area with tons of potential. Love all the inspiration pictures…I'm knee deep in my dining room makover.


  22. Rebecca says on July 20, 2010

    I vote to leave the breakfast nook as is!!! (sorry Sean)…It's definitely on my top 10 list when we uprade to a bigger home! Are you gonna do built in window seating too?


  23. Mrs. Fitz says on July 20, 2010

    Miss Money took my idea… compromise with some cushy chairs that can be pulled away from the table and turned to face out the window (if that's what Sean envisioned as a reading room). You can have the best of both worlds. I would love love love to have a bright, sunny space to start the morning.


  24. Jen says on July 20, 2010

    In our home whomever is more invested in the decision gets to “win” – the person who cares more or whom it would affect more.

    Do you do the cooking and spend more time in the kitchen? You get to decide how much work space is necessary. Do you want the breakfast nook but DH really, really, really wants the reading nook? He gets his way.

    If you still can't decide, then I'd look at resale value – I think a breakfast nook would be more widely needed by future buyers than a reading nook.


  25. Amanda says on July 20, 2010

    oh how i know disagreements like this all too well. ;) i agree with the vintage slipcovered loveseat idea on one side and chairs on the other. that area looks meant to be a breakfast nook, so i'd for sure leave it as just that, with a “spot” for reading to appease Sean too. :)

    as for the light fixture, i'm a sucker for crystal chandeliers in a bedroom but think a wire/lantern one would look lovely in your dining area.

    WHATEVER you both decide will look amazing as it always does.


  26. Shauna says on July 20, 2010

    I'd rather enjoy the windows while eating breakfast…while reading you are staring a book anyways!


  27. Elisabeth says on July 21, 2010

    I agree with you, a place to eat is pretty important, and you'll find as kids grow- they will never make themselves a snack, carry it to a dining room table (esp in a separate room) and eat it all nice and formal like that! Plus, I like to be around everybody while I'm working in the kitchen.


  28. AnaLisa says on August 1, 2010

    Definitely leave it as an eat-in-kitchen breakfast nook. That beautiful space will sell your home should you ever decide to move. It is lovely with all the windows and light coming in. As for the styles. Pic #5 the chandelier & rustic chairs are beautiful together. Pic #6 is definitely my style with the fun turquoise chairs and lime green accents (LOVE IT!), Loving the green hydrangeas in pic #7. If you're leaving the table and chairs as is which are beautiful, I think you should add a small rectangle pillow on each chair in a fun turquoise pattern, then green hydrangeas in the middle of the table. :) Love your space Holly! Don't you have two living rooms? One with the L-shaped sectional and one long white sofa? I'd say take away the long white sofa and make a reading nook there. :) Not like I really know your house… LOL.. just a thought. Have fun!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s